2027 RSA Institute: “Rhetoric/AI: Destructive Pleasures, Cruel Optimisms, and Reorienting Problematics”

From June 7 – 10, 2027, I’ll be co-leading an RSA seminar with Gavin Johnson of Texas Christian University about critical and rhetorical approaches to artificial intelligence! The seminar will be equal parts reading/discussion, writing workshop, and resource-sharing. If you are working on critical and humanistic projects related to artificial intelligence, come join us for an awesome week in Louisville, KY! The session description appears below.

Recent Publications by the Session Leaders:

About the Seminar

Why do people opt into technologies they recognize as dangerous? How can we simultaneously name AI’s destruction—environmental damage, hypersurveillance, data extraction, epistemic degradation—and still justify the pleasures of using it? Existing scholarship in rhetoric and AI has converged on a set of commonplaces about disruption, harm, and utility, but these accounts remain reactive, stranded in a synchronic present too thin to support durable critique. This seminar argues that understanding AI’s affective-rhetorical realities requires a vocabulary for destruction-as-pleasure that doesn’t rely on mystification—the assumption that people acquiesce to harmful conditions only because they’ve been deceived. Drawing on the death drive (Edelman) and cruel optimism (Berlant) as well as necropolitics (Mbembe) and rhetorical critiques of AI (Hallsby; Wang), we develop realist, sympathetic, and strategic accounts of AI’s proliferation, treating self-destructive attachment as intelligible rather than simply false consciousness.


These accounts anchor five interlocking problematics: the death drive––pleasure principle continuum structuring AI adoption; AI as an “undead” technology that revives older logics of racialized and extractive violence; the kakoethos, or pathological (bad) character, of the AI founder class; a hypercapitalist antihumanism that renders human judgment and labor increasingly worthless; and a shift in surveillance from panoptic observation to anticipatory foreclosure. Together, these threads work toward a shared rhetorical vocabulary capable of naming destruction and pleasure at once while being durable enough to outlast the boosterism/doomerism cycle that continually resets public debate.
Through participant-driven discussion, short writing tasks, and collaborative exchange, this seminar invites scholars in rhetoric, communication, and writing studies to build new critical and pedagogical responses to AI’s affective hold.
Aims

Across five interlocking problematics, this seminar works toward a shared rhetorical vocabulary for AI critique. Our aim is to articulate with participants a way of naming destruction and pleasure together without collapsing either into false consciousness, but durable enough to outlast the next reset of the boomerism/doomerism cycle.

By the end of the seminar, participats will.

  1. Apply rhetorical, affective, and ideological criticism to account for AI’s destruction-as-pleasure;
  2. Analyze the asymmetrical harms AI enacts on raced, gendered, disabled, and geographically situated communities, and explain how these harms are naturalized through surveillance, hypercapitalism, and antihumanist logics of dispossession;
  3. Situate AI developers’ ideological commitments––and the affective habitus of kakoethos that sustains them––within the broader systems of extraction and value that AI’s proliferation depends on; and
  4. Develop strategies rhetorical responses capable of holding critique open against the boosterism/doomerism cycle that otherwise forecloses sustained, rhetorical imagining.

Grounding/Reorientations

Why do people opt into technologies they recognize as dangerous? How can we simultaneously name AI destruction––environmental damage, hypersurveillance, data extraction, epistemic degradation––and still justify the pleasures of using it? Scholarship in rhetoric and AI has so far lacked the vocabulary to account for this tension, converging instead on several commonplaces: that AI’s rhetoricity emerges from its disruptive operations in/of rhetoric (Wang “Post-rhetoric”; Graham and Majdik; Hallsby); that AI enacts asymmetrical material harm on communities and infrastructures (Edwards; Crawford); that AI creates wicked problems for education, especially in writing and communication courses (Sano Franchini et al.; Davis et al.); and that, notwithstanding these harms, AI offers utility for research and teaching and AI literacy is an essential technology for future success (MacArthur; Ranade, Saravia, and Johri). Each commonplace leads to the same rhetorical problem: it seems impossible to say anything about AI that is not purely reactive or stranded in a synchronic moment too thin to support durable critique.

This RSA seminar argues that accounting for the affective-rhetorical realities of AI requires a way to articulate and explain destruction-as-pleasure without relying on mystification, which we understand as the assumption that people acquiesce to conditions against their own interest only because they have been deceived, distracted, or ideological captured. We turn to concepts like the death drive (Edelman) and cruel optimism (Berlant) as frameworks for understanding self-destructive attachments as intelligible, even rational, and an affective structure the rhetorical studies must reckon with directly if our critiques are to effectively reorient AI discourse and its material impacts.

Three accounts follow this reorientation.

  • A realist account attends to how AI plugs into existing systems of value and extraction rather than treating it as a genuinely novel technological frontier. AI, therefore, is best understood not as disembodied intelligence but as a planetary infrastructure that does not live outside of imperialism, militarism, and white supremacy as a novel force but, rather, mimics and extends their organizing logics (Katz; Crawford; Edwards); its power lies in how it reactivates older logics of disposition/dispossession.
  • A sympathetic account attends to the centrality of self-destructive pleasure for developers and subscribers alike, rather than assuming that adoption occurs only through rhetorical deception or coercion. AI developers marshal a substantial repertoire of “ugly feelings” such as paranoia, envy, and anxiety as the ‘“normal” experience of having been “plugged in” to a digital sphere that claims to think on the user’s behalf. While scholars like Sianne Ngai locate the ugly feelings of modernism in the bourgeois subject’s felt powerlessness, the ugly feelings of AI emerge from participation in, felt inertia toward, and cyclical in/validation of the self as social-emotional regression branded as inevitable transformative progress.
  • A strategic account attends to the disproportionate harms of AI through affective registers like shame, parody, and satire to counter the boosterism/doomerism cycle that currently structures public discourse, a cycle that forecloses sustained critique by continually resetting the terms of debate. Understanding affect as a circulating, public economy (Ahmed; Wang “The Banality”), brings into view attempts to navigate harm through satire and parody (Morgan), which argues holds critique open in the face of progressive narratives of political neutrality and techno-utopian fantasies.

Interlocking Problematics

To develop and test these reorienting accounts, this seminar addresses five interlocking subject areas or problematics.

Death Drive––Pleasure Principle
The first problematic concerns the incentive structures of neoliberal capitalism alongside the embodied urges that make LLMs and other AI technologies feel pleasurable because it reduces discomfort or tension. With respect to the death drive, AI developers and their philosophical champions (e.g., longtermists, effective altruists) frame AI maximalism as an “end” to the status quo, transforming labor, education, political participation, and health care. Beyond the literal harm of data-center expansion, mineral extraction, and community health impact, the death drive names a fetishistic attachment to ending the anarchronistic present to realize a utopic afterlife facilitated by chatbots and autonomous agents ruled over by a techno-oligarchy (Gebru and Torres; Taskale). The pleasure principle, meanwhile, is experienced as relief from mundane labor while doing nothing to quell the global demands for labor, resources, and energy; AI, in fact, intensifies these demands enforcing pain in the Global South as much as it provides relief for the so-called “first world” (Mejias and Couldry). The twin processes of hurtling toward a utopic/apocalyptic end and the deferred (and deceptive) promise of pleasurable relief form two theoretical touchstones that inform our empathic approach to AI, seeking to understand the motives and the affective experiences of those who are closest to it.

AI as an Undead Technology
AI is “undead” in two senses. On the one hand, following Tamara Kneese, AI literally resurrects––it creates holographic simulacra of the dead and revives the voice and tone of living authors via agentic simulations. On the other, following the theoretical trajectory of Eric King Watts and Ruha Benjamin, we connect the present age of autonomous robots and disembodied labor to the ongoing harms of chattel slavery and mass incarceration: not a rupture or departure from the past but a continuation of different forms of founding violence. The so-called “dream” of an artificial agent completing mundane, time-consuming tasks hearkens to earlier reductions of human action to inhuman motion, enabling beneficiaries to act as if there is no physical, emotional, environmental, or economic cost. AI, in other words, is the most contemporary manifestation of the undead zombie: a body devoid of humanity whose social and rhetorical function is to support capitalist consumption, cultivate apathy toward a laboring caste, and produce goods without claim to the underlying intellectual property. Perversely, AI’s documented effects (cognitive offloading, reduction of stress tolerance) turn addicted users into the very unthinking, unmoving, all-consuming automata that AI is meant to embody.

AI Founders and Kakoethos
Emphasizing the pleasurable affects associated with AI developers, we foreground the utility of kakoethos as a descriptive term of art for the extractive impulses and prurient indulgences of the AI founder class. Kakoethos may be defined as “pathologically bad character,” in the sense that it is fixated on downplaying the humanity of users and dissenters, inflicting punishment as a motivational strategy, and seeking emotional release in the form of mastery over marketplace competitors. Rather than a theory of superstructural interest, our emphasis is on the limited affective habitus cultivated by the ultra-wealthy seeking to enforce the inevitability of artificial intelligence as inextricable from quotidian life (Daub). Supported by philosophical commonplaces including “the sovereign individual,” “superintelligence,” and “the dark enlightenment,” the affective worlds of this superstratum of the 1% rely upon a continuous justification of exceptionality and elitism on the part of the plutocrat-founder caste.

Hypercapitalist Antihumanism
Where kakoethos describes the affective habitus of the founder class, hypercapitalist antihumanism names the logic that habitus serves. Following Mark Fisher’s account of capitalist realism––the foreclosure of any horizon beyond capital in which it is preferable to imagine the end of the world rather than the end of capitalism––AI marks a phase in which even human labor and cognition becomes redundant and actually slows economic accumulation. This is antihumanism in an active sense, not the philosophical decentering of the human subject but the practical devaluation of human worth when value cannot be extracted (Daniel). Achille Mbembe’s concept of necropolitics offers clarification to AI’s task of sorting populations into those whose lives are optimized, personalized, and rendered legible for capital and those whose exposure to harm is the precondition of that optimization. In naming hypercapitalist antihumanism as both philosophy and infrastructure, we highlight how the more AI founders and their rhetorics promise to expand human capacity, the more it forecloses the conditions under which human life, labor, and judgement retain value at all.

Surveillance
AI’s proliferation depends on a shift in the modality of surveillance from purely panoptic toward anticipatory. Shoshana Zuboff’s account of surveillance capitalism describes a mode of power less interested in watching and oriented toward shaping or even foreclosing possibilities before they occur. The predictive apparatus relies on algorithmic bias to reproduce and naturalize racialized, gendered, and ableist harm under the alibi of neutral computation (Noble). Building on rhetorical approaches to AI and other surveillant technologies (Graham and Majdik; Banville and Johnson), we argue that surveillance is laundered as convenience, personalization, or care, which are the same pleasures that, per our opening problematic, make its harms bearable or even desirable. Surveillance, thus, loops back into the death drive––pleasure principle continuum wherein to be watched, predicted, and optimized is presented as a form of being and being known, and the resulting pleasure is rhetorically inseparable from the harm it conceals.

“Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie” at the 2026 National Communication Association (and more updates)!

On Friday, Nov. 20 from 1:00 – 2:15 pm, I will be responding to a panel about my book, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie, joined by luminaries Kristen Einertson, Kimberlyn Harrison, Gavin Johnson, Jenny Rice, and Eric King Watts. For folks interested in teaching from the book in the Spring, it’s available open access, but I will also have a copy to give away at the session—we’d love to see you!

Right after that session (from 2:30-3:45) I’ll also be in scholar’s office hours, if you want to continue the conversation there! There’s also another opportunity to pick up a free copy of the book at the Public Address Division Book Cafe on Saturday, Nov. 21 from 11:00 – 12:15 pm, where the book will be featured alongside other amazing work published in the past year!

I am also slated to present on “30 Years of Deconstructing Communication” on Thursday, Nov. 19 from 11:00 – 12:15 pm. I won’t be there in person, but if you’re interested in hearing my remarks on “Deconstruction and the Secret” you can find them here:

Hope to see you this year!

–Atilla

“Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie”: New Recordings, Podcasts, Press, and Upcoming Events

I’m happy to share that in Spring 2026, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie: Forms of the Secret in US Political Rhetoric has received a lot of attention! Below, you’ll find a brief summary of those events with links to video recordings, podcasts, press releases, and upcoming book events!

The Big Rhetorical Podcast

I was delighted to Dr. Chase Woods of Texas A&M University, Commerce about the book in April! The interview is featured on Spotify and Apple Podcasts for those who want to listen in. Our chat covers a lot, and provides the most accessible introduction to the book’s arguments about how secrecy and surveillance are structuring, rhetorical features of the present political polycrisis.

Listen in here!

College of Liberal Arts Newsletter

Most recently, I was interviewed by Bayleigh Bergner of the University of Minnesota’s College of Liberal Arts for a short feature on Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie. I answer questions about the book’s argument, the future of secrecy, the origins of the book, and what’s next!

Check out the interview here!

Chapter-by-Chapter Recordings

As part of a Spring 2026 undergraduate course (4xxx-level, “The Rhetoric of Secrecy and Surveillance”) I assembled synoptic recorded lectures to correspond with five of the chapters (“The secret in/of discourse, the scandal, the dogwhistle, the leaker, and the detective). The full suite of recorded lectures for “The Rhetoric of Secrecy and Surveillance” is also available for viewing and/or use in advanced undergraduate courses.

The chapter-by-chapter lectures can be accessed here.

You can also access the full Spring 2026 class here.

The Page 99 Test

Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie was also featured on “The Page 99 Test” blog, which offers brief, synoptic overviews of recently released books based on what appears on … you guessed it, page 99.

You can read the entry (and about what appears on that page) here.

Book Release Event

On Wed, Mar 18, 2026, the Department of Race, Indigeneity, Disability, Gender, and Sexuality Studies (RIDGS) at the University of Minnesota hosted a release party for Sovereign, Settler, Leaker Lie. The event was hosted by Kyra Bowar (Communication Studies at the University of Minnesota) and featured superlative responses from Dr. Ira Allen (University of Northern Arizona) and Dr. Palita Chunsaengchan (University of Minnesota, Twin Cities).

You can access a recording of the book event from 3/18 HERE.

More Book-Related Events

In late May, I will be presenting at the biennial Rhetoric Society of America conference in Portland, OR, where there will be two panels featuring Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie. Please mark your calendars if you’re going to be at the conference!

  • On Friday, May 22 (4:15-5:30pm), I will be presenting on “The Nothing that is Something: Conspiracy, Secrecy, and Audience in Our Inverted World” with Drs. Paul Johnson (University of Pittsburgh), Joseph Packer (Central Michigan University), Calum Matheson (University of Pittsburgh), and Johanna Hartelius (University of Texas at Austin). The panel will feature responses to both Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie and to Joseph Packer and Ethan Stoneman’s Cypher Culture: Conspiracy, Pronoia, and the Messages that Were Not There (Louisiana State University Press).
  • On Saturday, May 23 (8:00-10:45am), I will present on the dual-session book panel “New Books in Rhetorical History/History of Rhetoric,” which is sponsored by the American Society for the History of Rhetoric (ASHR). This dual book panel will feature a number of recently published books and their authors, including Derek Handley (Struggle for the City, Penn State University Press) , José Izaguirre (Becoming La Raza, Penn State University Press), Michael Steudeman (Absence of National Feeling, University Press of Mississippi), Emily Winderman (Back-Alley Abortion, Johns Hopkins University Press), Noor Ghazal Aswad (Searching for Solidarity, Ohio State University Press), Mary Triece (Radical Advocate, University of Alabama Press), and Sara VenderHaagen (Community and Critique, University of South Carolina Press).

About Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie

If you are interested in purchasing a copy, please use the code HALLSBY at www.ohiostatepress.org to receive 30% off of the paperback version. This book will be freely available in an open access edition thanks to TOME (Toward an Open Monograph Ecosystem)—a collaboration of the Association of American Universities, the Association of University Presses, and the Association of Research Libraries—and the generous support of the University of Minnesota Libraries. Learn more at the TOME website, available at openmonographs.org. An open access copy of the monograph is also currently available to view at The Ohio State University’s Knowledge Bank repository.

Publication and Upcoming Book Event on 3/18! Sovereign, Settler, Leaker Lie: Forms of the Secret in U.S. Political Rhetoric

You can access a recording of the book event from 3/18 HERE.

I’m thrilled to announce that Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie: Forms of the Secret in U.S. Political Rhetoric, was published with Ohio State University Press earlier this month!

If you are interested in purchasing a copy, please use the code HALLSBY at www.ohiostatepress.org to receive 30% off of the paperback version. This book will be freely available in an open access edition thanks to TOME (Toward an Open Monograph Ecosystem)—a collaboration of the Association of American Universities, the Association of University Presses, and the Association of Research Libraries—and the generous support of the University of Minnesota Libraries. Learn more at the TOME website, available at openmonographs.org. An open access copy of the monograph is also currently available to view at The Ohio State University’s Knowledge Bank repository.

Book Release Event. There will also be a online-accessible book release event on Wed, Mar 18, 2026 from 4 – 5:30 PM hosted by the Department of Race, Indigeneity, Disability, Gender, and Sexuality Studies (RIDGS) at the University of Minnesota. There will be a book raffle and the event will be hosted by Kyra Bowar (Communication Studies at the University of Minnesota) with responses from Dr. Ira Allen (University of Northern Arizona) and Dr. Palita Chunsaengchan (University of Minnesota, Twin Cities). Please follow this link to register for this event!

About this book. In Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie: Forms of the Secret in US Political Rhetoric, Atilla Hallsby argues that secrets play a pivotal role in organizing political discourse in the United States. Hallsby takes up contemporary case studies—ranging from the Valerie Plame scandal during the George W. Bush presidency, to the use of Saul Alinsky’s name as a partisan codeword for politicizing Obama’s Blackness, to Chelsea Manning’s public naming and outing—to show how dramatic revelations increasingly fail to produce meaningful change and instead reproduce entrenched racial, gendered, and colonial hierarchies.

Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie tells two stories. The first concerns the epistemic, historical, and rhetorical precedents for the secret’s prolonged crises. This story is laid out in chapters 1–2, which address the secret as an object and as a method, respectively. Chapter 1 (“The Secret Episteme”) recounts a genealogy of the secret, arguing for it as a form of knowledge whose primary conceit is the concealment of knowledge. Chapter 2 (“The Secret in and of Discourse”) furnishes the theoretical grounding for this book and introduces the phrasing “in and of discourse” to point to the secret’s divided structure.

The second story concerns the secret and its formal variations in the early twenty-first century and features the scandal, dog whistle, leaker, and detective. These chapters also pair a specific variation of the secret with a distinct hegemonic context. Beyond the implicit reference to John LeCarre’s famous spy novel, Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy, these chapters also lend the book’s title its performative twist: The scandal centers sovereign power and white supremacy, the settler is associated with the detective, and highlights the pervasiveness of settler colonialism in popular and political culture, the leaker is associated with the national security state vulnerability, and features a national context of heterosexual and cisgender normativity, and the lie is associated with the dogwhistle, and foregrounds racism and anti-Blackness. Beginning with George W. Bush and ending with Joseph R. Biden, these chapters are semi-chronological and seek to reflect on the secret’s forms as precedent for Donald Trump’s first and second presidential administrations.

The core feature of these interlinked moments of crisis is the secret: a rhetorical patterning of political life organized by specific forms, each one lending a familiar shape to the shadows of American empire. These forms, theorized here as tropes, connect decades of secrets, linking the George W. Bush administration’s War on Terror to the Trump-era reemergence of “deep state” conspiracy theories. As an extension of secrecy and surveillance studies, and with the aim of attaining a more accountable and just form of US governmentality, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie explains how still-unfolding political realities in the United States emerged, transformed, and regenerate.

Praise for Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie.

“Much work on the secret skirts over its rhetorical form and associated tropes, but Hallsby has written a rigorous, capacious, and highly engaging account that situates the secret historically and culturally. Essential reading for those interested in the politics and aesthetics of secrecy.” —Clare Birchall, author of Radical Secrecy: The Ends of Transparency in Datafied America

“Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie generatively brings rhetorical studies into conversation with surveillance studies to offer important expansions and correctives to the study of secrecy. Drawing on a rich historical archive, Hallsby powerfully illustrates the secret’s material impacts and entanglements with racial, sexual, colonial, and gendered violences.”” —Mia Fischer, author of Terrorizing Gender: Transgender Visibility and the Surveillance Practices of the U.S. Security State

“Presented from a psychoanalytic perspective that refuses to collapse into binaries of suspicion and faith, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie is both reassuring for its ability to ‘name’ contemporary rhetorical dynamics and sobering because, as Freud once put it, we are not masters of our own house.” —Joshua Gunn, author of Political Perversion: Rhetorical Aberration in the Time of Trumpeteering

“Smart, playful, and theoretically sophisticated, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie introduces us to the hard truths of secrecy in American politics. A one-of-a-kind book.” —Joshua Reeves, coauthor of The Prison House of the Circuit: Politics of Control from Analog to Digital

“This analytically sophisticated book offers a captivating exploration of the often-destructive role of political secrets in society. Whether found in conspiracy theories, national security leaks, or fabrications supporting war, Atilla Hallsby shows how secrets powerfully shape collective knowledge and legitimize forms of violence.” —Torin Monahan, author of Crisis Vision: Race and the Cultural Production of Surveillance

Updated Edition of Reading Rhetorical Theory!

As folks prepare for a new semester, I wanted to encourage you to check out version 2.0 of Reading Rhetorical Theory: Speech, Representation, and Power. This online textbook is the edited and expanded version of the undergraduate rhetorical theory resources first made available on the main page of The Rhetoric UnTextbook. The book does not need to be assigned as a whole; rather, the individual chapters are intended to be assigned as might fit the needs of rhetoric instructors’ preferred order and topics.

New Additions/Chapters

Reading Rhetorical Theory has been re-organized into three sections, with a new, brief introduction to each: (1) Speech, (2) Representation, and (3) Power. These also now contain four new chapters by guest authors!

  •  Chapter 4: Rhetoric and the Freedom of Expression by Emily Berg Paup examines the multifaceted nature of the right to freedom of speech and its development and connection to the rhetorical tradition. It will explore these ideas through their theoretical foundations, historical development, and the ongoing struggle to ensure their equitable application.
  • Chapter 9: The Public Sphere by Angela M. McGowan-Kirsch explores rhetoric and symbolic action in the context of civic engagement. It focuses on actions related to systems’ efforts on individuals and communities, individuals’ activities to participate in their communities, active citizenship, symbolic actions that have built stronger communities, and the advancement of social justice in democracy.
  • Chapter 10: Counterpublics by Carlos A. Flores and Sarah E. Jones focuses on the relationship between theories of the public sphere and rhetorical theory. The first part of this chapter presents a detailed history and foundational definitions of the public sphere, while the second explores critiques of the foundational concept of the public sphere vis-à-vis counterpublics and several contemporary case studies.
  • Chapter 15: Latine Rhetorical Theory by Robert Mejia and Diana I. Martínez discusses the emergence of Latine rhetorical theory and criticism in the field of communication. Latine scholars and non-Latine scholars have worked to bring Latine rhetoric, concepts, and topics into the field.  It offers the rhetorical concepts and methods of the prominent Chicana feminist Gloria Anzaldúa, the nepantla rhetorical methodology, the groundbreaking theologian Gustavo Gutiérrez, and his framework of radical hope.

Future Updates

For folks who are more familiar with my Rhetoric UnTextbook blog site, please know that this resource is still up and running, and you can still access the original undergraduate-level rhetorical theory, graduate-level rhetorical theory, and upper-level undergraduate secrecy surveillance course resources. In future semesters, however, I intend to concentrate on updates to Reading Rhetorical Theory, including

  • AI policy guidance and resource glossary
  • Citation information for each chapter
  • A glossary and chapter keywords
  • Updates to “digital rhetoric” concerning AI/LLM technologies
  • Updates to “the rhetoric of secrecy and surveillance” related to the release of Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie

Additional Resources

As always, I am happy to share additional teaching resources related to this textbook with verified instructors. quiz and exam questions to this email. These include exam/quiz questions, recent syllabi, written assignment descriptions, a day-to-day agenda, and recently used slides. Additionally, I deeply appreciate correction notices for content and/or broken links and have set up a survey for instructors and students to provide their informal feedback about what is working and what could use further improvement. The book is also listed on the Open Textbook Library – I would greatly appreciate your review if you have used the resource!

Open for Submissions

Finally, should you and/or a coauthor wish to contribute chapters or content to Reading Rhetorical Theory, we are open for future submissions. Version 2.0 benefited from a PALM (Partnership for Affordable Learning Materials) grant awarded by the University of Minnesota Libraries, which enabled us to compensate contributors for their work. We would be glad to continue developing this model for equitable publication. We seek additional chapters on the intersections of rhetorical theory with disability, race, gender, activism, sound studies, and other related topics. Contributors would be listed as authors on the textbook and would be cited in the style of an edited volume. Please reach out if you are interested!

“A Copious Void” Recieves Golden Anniversary Monograph Award from the National Communication Association

Convention logo for the 2025 National Communication Association Convention, which includes an image of clouds and bubbles assembled into the shape of a hot air balloon. The name of the convention theme is also included: "Communicate to Elevate."

I’m honored to have received the National Communication Association’s Golden Anniversary Monograph Award for my essay, “A Copious Void: Rhetoric as Artificial Intelligence 1.0”!

I’m floored in particular that folks have found the essay to be useful as ai development has intensified in dire, dangerous, and ever more death-centred ways since 2024. I’m so grateful to S. Scott Graham and Zoltan Majdik for their support for this piece and their willingness to include it in their special issue. I am also indebted to Joshua Trey Barnett’s editorial guidance. Truly, this essay would not have turned out as it did had it not been for them and the anonymous reviewers, all of whom made the product immeasurably better.

To that end, please check out the entire “Rhetoric of/with AI” special issue. It is excellent and deserves your attention if you are engaged with this particular topic. There is an amazing introduction from S. Scott Graham & Zoltan Majdik, incredible work on reproductive surveillance from Kem-Laurin L. & Randy Allen Harris, incisive, care-driven criticism on ai as a form of time-traveling memory from Emma Bedor Hiland, genre-based methods from Ryan Omizo & Bill Hart-Davidson, timely reflections on #WallStreetBets from Misti Yang & Zoltan Majdik, and a spicy conclusion from Casey Boyle. Please check it out!

Coming Soon! Sovereign, Settler, Leaker Lie: Forms of the Secret in U.S. Political Rhetoric

To be published by The Ohio State University Press in February 2026

Pre-orders available at the link below. This book will also be released as an open-access title. If you are interested in a desk copy once it becomes available, please reach out! I am happy to respond to requests given availability/demand. Stay tuned and I hope you check it out!

https://ohiostatepress.org/books/titles/9780814216057.html

Book Jacket Description

In Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie, Atilla Hallsby argues that secrets play a pivotal role in organizing political discourse in the United States. Hallsby takes up contemporary case studies—ranging from the Valerie Plame scandal during the George W. Bush presidency, to the use of Saul Alinsky’s name as a partisan codeword for politicizing Obama’s Blackness, to Chelsea Manning’s public naming and outing—to show how dramatic revelations increasingly fail to produce meaningful change and instead reproduce entrenched racial, gendered, and colonial hierarchies.

The core feature of these interlinked moments of crisis is the secret: a rhetorical patterning of political life organized by specific forms, each one lending a familiar shape to the shadows of American empire. These forms, theorized here as tropes, connect decades of secrets, linking the George W. Bush administration’s War on Terror to the Trump-era reemergence of “deep state” conspiracy theories. As an extension of secrecy and surveillance studies, and with the aim of attaining a more accountable and just form of US governmentality, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie explains how still-unfolding political realities in the United States emerged, transformed, and regenerate.

Reception

“Much work on the secret skirts over its rhetorical form and associated tropes, but Hallsby has written a rigorous, capacious, and highly engaging account that situates the secret historically and culturally. Essential reading for those interested in the politics and aesthetics of secrecy.” —Clare Birchall, author of Radical Secrecy: The Ends of Transparency in Datafied America

“Presented from a psychoanalytic perspective that refuses to collapse into binaries of suspicion and faith, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie is both reassuring for its ability to ‘name’ contemporary rhetorical dynamics and sobering because, as Freud once put it, we are not masters of our own house.” —Joshua Gunn, author of Political Perversion: Rhetorical Aberration in the Time of Trumpeteering

“Smart, playful, and theoretically sophisticated, Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie introduces us to the hard truths of secrecy in American politics. A one-of-a-kind book.” —Joshua Reeves, coauthor of The Prison House of the Circuit: Politics of Control from Analog to Digital

“Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie generatively brings rhetorical studies into conversation with surveillance studies to offer important expansions and correctives to the study of secrecy. Drawing on a rich historical archive that includes figures like Alan Turing, Saul D. Alinsky, Valerie Plame Wilson, and Chelsea Manning, Hallsby powerfully illustrates how secrets are not just in but of discourse. In so doing, he importantly foregrounds the secret’s material impacts and entanglements with racial, sexual, colonial, and gendered violences.” —Mia Fischer, author of Terrorizing Gender: Transgender Visibility and the Surveillance Practices of the U.S. Security State

“This analytically sophisticated book offers a captivating exploration of the often-destructive role of political secrets in society. Whether found in conspiracy theories, national security leaks, or fabrications supporting war, Atilla Hallsby shows how secrets powerfully shape collective knowledge and legitimize forms of violence.” —Torin Monahan, author of Crisis Vision: Race and the Cultural Production of Surveillance

“Rhetoric Unbound” Presentation on 10/26/2025: “From the Secret Report to the Deep State.”

On October 26, I will deliver a “Rhetoric Unbound” lecture as part of a series developed by Dr. Joshua Trey Barnett of Pennsylvania State University. The talk, entitled “Twisted Endings: From the Secret Report to the Deep State,” will take place at 8.00 p.m. Eastern via Zoom. The lecture will last 30 minutes and will be followed by an audience-led discussion.

To register for the lecture, click here.

Although the lecture previews my forthcoming monograph, it is comprised of materials that were ultimately not included in the book. The presentation is the shadow side of the book’s conclusion, foregrounding Daniel Patrick Moynihan as a key public figure whose troubled political legacy foreshadowed many of the secret exigencies — urgencies marked by concealment, hiddenness, and conspiratorial rumination — that characterize current crises in the United States.

Lecture Description

Drawing on material excised from Sovereign, Settler, Leaker, Lie (Ohio State University Press, forthcoming 2026), this presentation argues that the secret is a dynamic and rhetorical interplay of absence and desire. Whereas the book addresses the rhetorical form of scandals, dogwhistles, national security leaks, and settler-detective narratives, this talk focuses on the connection between the Moynihan Report (1965), the Pentagon Papers (1971), the Senate Intelligence Committee Report on Torture (2014), and “the deep state.”

The connection between these texts is encapsulated in two principles: (1) there is always a “beyond” to the secret, or that hidden meanings come to light through the restoration of rhetorical context, and (2) the secret is that there is no secret, or that much of what is concealed is a going-through-the-motions that repeats a similar form across many, temporally distant, instances.

I critique the appropriation and dilution of appeals to transparency in contemporary political discourse, particularly in reference to conspiracy theories like the “deep state.” Such theories do not just distort public perceptions by fostering mistrust while masquerading as revelations; they underscore the necessity of discerning the secret’s form and function, a continuous thread that stretches from Daniel Patrick Moynihan to Donald Trump.

Pictured Above: Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan and William F. Buckley. Credit: © Wally McNamee/CORBIS; Copyright: © Corbis. All Rights Reserved. Public Domain Mark 1.0 Universal PDM 1.0 Deed. https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/

New In Print: “What is Rhetoric Enough? Forms IN and OF Rhetoric Scholarship”in the Journal for the History of Rhetoric

“What is Rhetoric Enough?” was initially presented as the keynote address for the 2024 Midwest Winter Workshop (MWW) hosted by the Department of Communication Arts at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Although much remains the same, it has been edited from its original outline format for readability and to include citations that were not in the original due to time constraints.

ARTICLE @ Journal for the History of Rhetoric

PROOFS/Article Pre-Print (nearly identical to final version)

MWW VERSION: You can also find the original talk, delivered at the Midwest Winter Workshop in 2024 here.

ABSTRACT: This article poses the question, What is rhetoric enough? as a provocation about the hurdles emerging scholars must traverse. The first is fear that their scholarship is not “enough” to meet the topical, theoretical, and evidentiary standards of rhetoric studies, while the second is the criticism that there is “too much” rhetoric in communication scholarship. Together, these create a wicked polarity. This article answers this question by drawing on the strategy of prepositional criticism, which posits “both/and” answers as affirmative rejoinders to “either/or” framings of rhetoric’s grounding in either tradition or transformation. To that end, it offers five provisions that elaborate distinct forms in and of rhetoric scholarship: (1) rhetoric can be understood as a contained feature in and productive effect of discourse; (2) exigencies define the context in and purpose of scholarship; (3) theory is embedded in and an enactment of rhetorical criticism; (4) community is invoked in and a creation of academic discourse; and (5) citation can be thought of as a way to document scholars’ due diligence in their writing and as an active habit or practice of constituting a conversation.

I am presently at work co-editing a forum with Ariel Seay- Howard of North Carolina State University, assembling a number of other contributors who also responded to this same prompt. The forum is based on a featured panel held at the National Communication Association (NCA) convention in 2024.

About this Essay

My intended audience was graduate students, and my objective was less to provide a comprehensive view of rhetorical studies and more to capture a snapshot of the field based on the community gathered for the 2024 MWW.

One feature that is less apparent in this version is that the many citations – especially those in second section – are drawn primarily from the published scholarship of MWW workshop leaders, many of whom were in the audience for this speech.

Acknowledgments

Thank you to Allyson Gross, Alicen Rushevics, Megan L. Zahay, and Ailea Merriam-Pigg for
their invitation to deliver this 2024 Midwest Winter Workshop (MWW) keynote address, aswell as to Rob Asen, Rob Howard, Jenell Johnson, and Allison Prasch, who are the most
generous interlocutors and incredible hosts.

At the MWW, Cara Finnegan, Rob Asen, and
Rachel Bloom-Pojar asked me important questions that have stuck with me as I edited this final version, and I am grateful to Emily Winderman for her suggestion to address each of the workshop’s faculty mentors. I’m also indebted to Ned O’Gorman for the opportunity to publish this keynote, the participants from the MWW whose encouragement nudged me
toward publishing this essay, and to Lauren Seitz for editorial guidance in bringing this to
print.

Finally, I wish to offer a special thanks to Ariel Seay-Howard, the “What is Rhetoric
Enough?” panelists at NCA 2024, and the Institute for Advanced Studies at the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities for their time, labor, and support for this project.

Open Access Textbook Updates in 2025

Some changes will be coming to the UnTextbook and Reading Rhetorical Theory in 2025!

The main chapters of the UnTextbook were published as an online textbook with the University of Minnesota Libraries in 2022 (https://open.lib.umn.edu/rhetoricaltheory/). Publishing this as an online textbook gave this resource an ISBN and allowed it to circulate more widely in online libraries like the OER Commons. As of September 2024, Reading Rhetorical Theory: Speech, Representation, and Power (RRT) has been adopted by more than 60 universities and colleges. The upcoming changes have to do with modifications to Reading Rhetorical Theory and to the front-page design of this website.

Reading Rhetorical Theory, the online textbook version of the UnTextbook of Rhetorical Theory. To view the book, go to https://open.lib.umn.edu/rhetoricaltheory

Find out more about RRT adoptions

If you have been using the UnTextbook or Reading Rhetorical Theory, I would love to have your feedback! I’m collecting testimonials from folks who have found these resources useful. I’ve set up this survey for folks, or you can send me a message at rhetoricaltheoryuntextbook-at-gmail-dot-com. Either would be greatly appreciated!

So, what’s changing?

Updates for Spring-Summer 2025

The UnTextbook is staying open, and you will still be able to access the course content posted there. By June-August 2025, however, some links may change, requiring updates to course syllabi before the Fall.

UPDATE #1: The UnTextbook of Rhetorical Theory

My plan is to replace the chapters on the main UnTextbook page with icons for the textbook and other course offerings:

  1. Reading Rhetorical Theory: Speech, Representation, and Power (this would direct you to the OER site).
  2. The (Undergraduate) UnTextbook Rhetorical Theory (you would be able to access the chapters currently posted on the main page).
  3. The (Graduate) UnTextbook of Rhetorical Theory.
  4. The Rhetoric of Secrecy and Surveillance.

UPDATE #2: Reading Rhetorical Theory

All Updates and Changes to RRT

The largest change to RRT is four new chapters from invited authors to Reading Rhetorical Theory in Spring 2025. This has required reorganizing the chapter order of that book. The new chapters include:

  • “The Public Sphere” by Angela McGowan Kirsch
  • “Counterpublics” by Carlos A. Flores and Sarah E. Jones
  • “Latine Rhetorical Theory” by Robert Mejia and Diana I. Martinez
  • “Rhetoric and the First Amendment” by Emily Berg Paup

Some things to note:

(1) the new chapters will not appear on the UnTextbook site.

(2) Although the order of the chapters is slightly changed as compared to what appears on this site, the content is identical (save for some new images).

(3) As always, there is no chapter 13.

(4) The links to “The Public Sphere” and “Counterpublics” will be ready in January 2025; the links to “Latinx Rhetoric(s)” and “Rhetoric and the First Amendment” will go live later.

(5) Finally, if you are considering switching from the UnTextbook to Reading Rhetorical Theory, know that the latter is more recently updated and has been copy-edited, meaning the content you’ll find there is likely more grammatically correct and up-to-date.

You can find updated links for the textbook below if you are looking to adjust your syllabus for an upcoming semester. The guest-authored chapters will go ‘live’ in early Spring semester 2025, but the links should stay consistent.

Updated ToC for Reading Rhetorical Theory

Part 1: Speech

Part 2: Representation

Part 3: Power

Assignments and Study Guides